Skip to content

Search

Gifts under $25

All Filters

All Filters

CLEAR SHOW 298 RESULTS
298 items
Scripture Heart Tassel Bible Bookmark
Rachel Brooks Design
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Scripture Cross Tassel Bible Bookmark
Rachel Brooks Design
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Angel of Light Tassel Bible Bookmark
Rachel Brooks Design
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Festive Feathers 500 Piece Foil Puzzle
Chronicle Books
Regular price
$17.99
Regular price
Joy Laforme Gingerbread Cottage 500 Piece Puzzle In A House
Chronicle Books
Regular price
$19.99
Regular price
Reindeer Snow Globe 48 Piece Mini Puzzle Ornament
Chronicle Books
Regular price
$7.99
Regular price
Liberty Vista 500 Piece Book Puzzle
Chronicle Books
Regular price
$19.99
Regular price
Nutcracker Magic 500 Piece Puzzle
Chronicle Books
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Enchanted Nutcracker 500 Piece Puzzle
Chronicle Books
Regular price
$16.99
Regular price
Christmas Gator Cocktail Napkins
Alexa Pulitzer
Regular price
$14
Regular price
Sardines Porcelain Trinket Dish
Idlewild
Regular price
$24
Regular price
Poinsettia Pattern & Red Paper Napkins (20 Folded Pieces)
Creative Co-op
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Mahjong Social Club Garden Flag
Whereable Art
Regular price
$24
Regular price
Jumbo Gumbo Crab Bowl
Youngberg & Co Inc
Regular price
$22
Regular price
Ivory Mini Pumpkin
Jessica Reynolds Art
Regular price
$22
Regular price
Green Gold Mini Pumpkin
Jessica Reynolds Art
Regular price
$22
Regular price
Cardinal Flour Sack Towel
Pamela Cassidy Designs
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Give Thanks Flour Sack Towel
Pamela Cassidy Designs
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Bountiful Flour Sack Towel
Pamela Cassidy Designs
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Almost Christmas Flour Sack Towel
Pamela Cassidy Designs
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Need a Little Christmas Flour Sack Towel
Pamela Cassidy Designs
Regular price
$16
Regular price
November Flour Sack Towel
Pamela Cassidy Designs
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Joyous Noel Flour Sack Towel
Pamela Cassidy Designs
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Amaryllis Flour Sack Towel
Pamela Cassidy Designs
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Autumn Flour Sack Towel
Pamela Cassidy Designs
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Verses for Mothers – Bible Verse Card Set with Display Stand
Callie Danielle
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Ca C'est Bon Spoonrest
The Parish Line
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Christmastime Bone China 21oz Soup Mug with Lid
tag
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Antique Brass Aluminum Holly Chamberstick Taper Holder
tag
Regular price
$22
Regular price
Ceramic Staffordshire Dog Ornament, 2 Available Styles - Left Facing
Creative Co-op
Regular price
$10
Regular price
More colors
Ceramic Staffordshire Dog Ornament, 2 Available Styles - Right Facing
Creative Co-op
Regular price
$10
Regular price
More colors
Gold Finish Resin Bee Ornament with Wire Legs
Creative Co-op
Regular price
$10
Regular price
Unglazed Base & Cream Reactive Glaze Stoneware Tree (Each One Will Vary)
Creative Co-op
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Gold Resin Textured Bird
K&K Interiors
Regular price
$22
Regular price
Gold & Pearl LED Tall Angel with Timer, 3 Available Styles - Gold & Pearl
K&K Interiors
Regular price
$20
Regular price
Outset Family Charades Game, Retro Design, Ages 10+
Outset Games and Cobble Hill Puzzles
Regular price
$20
Regular price
Family Charades Card Game
Outset Games and Cobble Hill Puzzles
Regular price
$12
Regular price
Pocket Angel, 5 Available Styles, Sold Individually
Sugarboo
Regular price
$12
Regular price
Bamboo Bread Board
French Home
Regular price
$24
Regular price
Groovy Christmas Trees Set of 2 Dishtowels
tag
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Silicone & Beech Wood Set of 3 Christmas Spatulas
tag
Regular price
$20
Regular price
Mini Xmas Nonstick Cake Pan, 6 Styles Available
tag
Regular price
$8
Regular price
Christmas Holly Bowl Cozy Potholder
tag
Regular price
$10
Regular price
Christmas Red Medium Groovy Spiral Glass Tree Decor
tag
Regular price
$22
Regular price
Merry & Bright Ornament Set of 2 Dishtowels
tag
Regular price
$20
Regular price
Groovy Reindeer Dishtowel
tag
Regular price
$10
Regular price
Christmas Tree Cookie Mug
tag
Regular price
$16
Regular price
Green Groovy Dotted Glass Tree Decor
tag
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Merry & Bright Set of 4 Cotton Cocktail Napkins
tag
Regular price
$18
Regular price
Disco Ball Set of 4 Cocktail Pick
tag
Regular price
$22
Regular price
Christmas Multi Glass Stainless Steel Disco Bottle Opener
tag
Regular price
$22
Regular price
Showing 50 of 298 products

Gifts under $25

Great Gifts Don't Have to Cost a Fortune

Discover a curated selection of gifts under $25 at Little Miss Muffin — thoughtfully chosen pieces that feel anything but budget. From charming children’s toys and playful accessories to beautiful home accents and sweet treats, every item in this collection is proof that the best gifts come from knowing exactly where to shop.

Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, holidays, teacher gifts, stocking stuffers, and every occasion in between — all in stock and ready to give.

  • Curated gifts $25 and under — all in stock & ready to ship
  • Children’s toys, accessories & playful gifts
  • Home accents, candles & lifestyle gifts
  • Faith-inspired keepsakes & devotional gifts
  • Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, teacher gifts & stocking stuffers
  • New arrivals added regularly — check back often!

Big love. Small price. Little Miss Muffin.